Cardiovascular exercises are great for burning fat. When your aim is to lose weight, it all comes down to a treadmill or a spinning bike for indoor exercises. These exercises raise the heart rate and burn off the calories. Both of these exercises provide great benefits for diabetes, stress, depression, and offer relaxation. But the question remains: spinning vs running: which one is better?
Spinning vs Running: A Comparative View
1. For Building Muscles
What is a spin bike good for? When you’re using a spinning bike, your quadriceps, glutes, calves, hip flexors, and shin muscles get worked out. The pedaling directly works on your quadriceps and with extra resistance, you can form muscles. Set the resistance to 60 revs/s, so your quadriceps and hamstrings can work on your “moving forward” motion. Some modern and top-rated spin bikes offer digital display and program feature. You can also incorporate interval training into your workout since it targets the lower legs more effectively. During the intervals, you can pedal while standing.
2. For Losing Weight
Running on a treadmill puts the entire body to work and not just the lower half of the body like a spinning bike. Since you’re pushing your bodyweight in a forward direction, you’ll be able to burn more calories. If a 165-lb person walks quickly on a treadmill, he’ll burn around 565 calories. If he does an incline, he can burn 700-800 calories. And if he runs on the machine, he can burn 800-1000 calories. If you can change your pace during walking or running on a treadmill, it will be 20% more effective. There are many benefits of spinning for weight loss but it requires more work.
3. For Intense Workout
There are several spinning exercise benefits since you get to do a variety of exercises with different results by applying different speeds. If you perform interval training on the bike, you get to burn your fat 36% faster and your cardiovascular fitness increases 13% faster than working out with the same speed on the treadmill. Some of the benefits you’ll get from a spinning bike are:
- Toned legs
- Longevity of heart
- Better lung capacity
If you cycle for about an hour, you can easily burn 250-700 calories. Don’t work on your pedal too fast. If you go 110 revs/s, only 40% of your energy will get utilized to propel the bike forward and 60% of the energy will go into pedaling.
You’ll also benefit from the bike more than you can on the treadmill when you’re working your joints. Running often stresses the spine, knees, hips, and ankle joints. But anyone with a dodgy knee can work on a bike. Working on a bike will provide the perfect cardiovascular workout without stressing the joints.
4. For Burning Calories
Running on treadmill helps burn more calories than a spinning bike using the same intensity. This has a lot to do with your positioning on the machines. Since the seat on a spinning bike supports your weight, you don’t have to put much effort into it while working out. But when you’re on a treadmill, you have to propel your entire body with its weight. This accounts for a more rigorous calorie burn than a spinning bike.
Is riding a bike good cardio? Although you can burn more calories on a treadmill in much less time than on a spinning bike, you can work more hours on a bike which is good for your cardiovascular health. Since you don’t have to put too much pressure while you’re on the spinning bike, your joints are comfortable and you feel like working out for longer. There are also variants of exercises available in a spinning bike. You can always work on the bike for a longer period of time to meet the calorie burn you’d get on a treadmill.
5. For Reducing Fat
You can perform High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) on both treadmill and spinning bikes. HIIT is the most effective way to reduce abdominal fat while retaining muscle mass. Both of the machines come with models that have built-in HIIT programs in their consoles. These programs work as great guidelines for your training. But the benefits of spinning everyday surpass the benefits of using a treadmill in terms of HIIT.
Looking at Both Machines Intricately
We’ve provided an overall comparison of both machines and talked about which machine serves which purpose best. Now, we’ll take our spinning vs running discussion one step further by overviewing each of their benefits and advantages separately.
- The predictable surface on the machine makes it easier for the runner than running outside
- You can control the speed, warming up and cooling down periods, how much energy is going to be spent, incline, etc.
- Most of the models come with safety shut down features
- You can create custom programs for the limited time you’re going to exercise on the machine
- You can track your progress by daily, weekly and monthly basis on many models. They usually have monitors for heart rate and steps
- Great for burning calories and fat with an incline feature.
- Doesn’t require as much effort on the joints as running outside
- People fit into the machine since it’s spacious
- You get to work on your knee joints, spine, ankle bones, and thighs
- You can do interval training on the machine
- Creates pressure on the lower back and the joints
- Limited programs
- The multitasking options while using this machine are limited
- Easy to trip with bad timing on one of the feet or distraction
- Injuries on treadmills can be severe
If you’re still wondering “is spinning a good workout,” we’ve compiled a list of both spinning benefits and disadvantages. Read our points before you go for a spinning bike for yourself or get yourself into a spinning class.
These are some of the health benefits of spinning:
- Muscles and ligaments of the legs get higher flexibility
- Not too much pressure is put into the lower back
- People with arthritis, back pain, balancing issues or bad knees can easily perform a spinning workout
- Doesn’t put too much load on the spine
- Many programs and preset workouts are available in almost all of the models
- You can multitask while working out
- You get to work on your abs, legs, buttocks and sometimes even arms with high intensity
- You can do interval training on the machine
- Doesn’t quite help in building bones
- Doesn’t burn too many calories
- Requires more intense program to burn off calories
- Can cause back pain and lower back strain while doing high-intensity workouts
- Doesn’t offer a full body workout. But you can always add weights or press-ups to your cycling
How to Get the Most out of Both?
Most people who take on one of these exercise machines usually go for burning calories and losing weight. You can select any one of the machines and work your way out towards your goal if you push yourself enough. You can start with simple jogging on the treadmill and gradually add incline to it for sprinting to get the most out of the machine.
You can incorporate both machines into your routine for aerobic fitness. The benefits of spinning twice a week are many. You can exercise on the treadmill one day and on the spinning bike the next day. People who only go for the treadmill can develop a knee problem and people who only go for the spinning bike are prone to getting a bad posture. This cross-training program will make you utilize both of the cardio methods. You can join a spin cycle class and get a treadmill at your home. Here are the muscle groups that get worked on each of the exercises:
|The Glutes||Gluteal Muscles|
|Arms and Abs||Arms and Abs|
|Upper and Lower Legs||Upper and Lower Legs|
|Core Muscles||Iliotibial Band|
As you can see, the chart shows the resemblance of the exercises. They’re quite similar in terms of the muscles they work on. However, the effect they have on the user’s body depends on the user’s age, body type, and health condition.
For achieving good cardiovascular health, toned legs, less weight, and less fat, spinning and running come at the top of the exercise list. The spinning vs running debate is legit but banal at the same time since a lot of issues dictate for a person which machine is best for him/her.
In terms of choosing a machine, you have to understand which machine is going to suit you best. This essentially means the exercises you feel comfortable doing and are going to keep doing. You also need to consider why you’re exercising. If you simply want to lose weight and you don’t have any issues with your back or joints, go for the treadmill. But if you also want to build up muscles and you have back or joint issues, go for a spinning bike for a more strenuous workout. We hope we’ve helped you with your confusion on exercise bike vs treadmill.